A Broadway Guide to NYC with John Skelley of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

New York City is a place where magic feels real—and for John Skelley, who currently plays Harry Potter on Broadway, that sense of wonder extends far beyond the stage. In this Broadway Guide to NYC, Skelley shares his journey to the Great White Way, what makes Harry Potter and the Cursed Child so special, and his favorite ways to experience the city like a local.

Meet John Skelley: Broadway’s Harry Potter

John Skelley stars as Harry Potter in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, bringing one of the most beloved literary characters to life in a whole new chapter. Set 19 years after the Battle of Hogwarts, the story follows Harry as a husband, father, and Ministry of Magic employee navigating life alongside his son, Albus.

“It’s 19 years after the Battle of Hogwarts, and Harry is a father of three, married to Ginny Weasley,” Skelley explains. “Harry’s middle child, Albus, is about to start school at Hogwarts and struggles with being the son of a famous father, while Harry struggles to be the father that he never had.”

From School Plays to Broadway

Skelley’s path to Broadway began early, performing in school productions where he quickly fell in love with the collaborative spirit of theater. That passion led him to professional work at The Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis, where he appeared in productions like The Importance of Being Earnest and A Long Day’s Journey Into Night.

After moving to New York in 2014 with his wife and fellow performer Maren Searle, he continued building his career in regional theater across the country. Now, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child marks his Broadway debut—a milestone role that blends spectacle with emotional depth.

Why Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Is a Must-See

For anyone new to Broadway, Skelley describes the show as an unforgettable theatrical experience.

“HPCC is a thrilling adventure featuring mind-blowing illusions and special effects, an incredible cast of actors, including the original Draco from the films, Tom Felton (through May 10), and a beautiful story about finding friends in unexpected places and how we’re all stronger together.”

While the production features stunning choreography by Steven Hoggett and a sweeping score by Imogen Heap, it’s important to note: this is a play—not a musical—making its visual storytelling and stagecraft all the more impressive.

What Makes Performing in NYC So Special

One of Skelley’s favorite parts of performing on Broadway is the audience itself—especially first-time theatergoers.

“A lot of families come to see the show, and for a lot of kids and adults, this is their first Broadway show,” he shares. “Seeing adults who grew up with these characters share their love of the wizarding world with a younger generation is really beautiful.”

It’s a reminder that Broadway isn’t just entertainment—it’s a shared experience that connects generations.

John Skelley’s NYC Tips for First-Time Visitors

Navigating New York City can feel like its own adventure, but Skelley has a few practical tips to help visitors make the most of their time:

• Avoid the empty subway car—there’s usually a reason it’s empty.
• Plan ahead: “Go to the bathroom before you get on the subway!”
• Walk whenever you can: The best discoveries often happen off the beaten path.

“If you allow yourself to wander, you never know who or what you’ll run into,” he says. (More subway tips here!)

Where to Go for a Night Out in NYC

When Skelley does get a night off, he gravitates toward the West Village for its laid-back charm and vibrant nightlife.

“I do love the West Village for fun dinner-and-drink spots. Just wandering into a bar that has live music can be an adventure in itself.”

It’s the kind of spontaneous experience that defines a true New York night out.

Favorite NYC Spots to Explore

For visitors looking to explore beyond Times Square, Skelley recommends a mix of history and nature:

• The Tenement Museum for an immersive look at NYC’s immigrant history.
• Central Park for iconic city greenery.
• Prospect Park and Fort Tryon Park for a more local feel.
• Inwood Hill Park, his personal favorite, offering a rare glimpse of untouched wilderness in Manhattan.

Where to Eat Like a Local

When it comes to dining, Skelley has a soft spot for two standout restaurants where he once worked:

• Hearth – A cozy Italian favorite in the East Village known for its seasonal, rustic dishes
• Balvanera – A vibrant Lower East Side spot serving elevated Argentinian cuisine

“Both have incredible food, amazing beverages, and impeccable service,” he says.

The Magic of New York City

For Skelley, what makes New York City truly special isn’t just its landmarks or theaters—it’s the unexpected moments.

“There’s something about the energy of New York that feels serendipitous,” he reflects. “I can’t tell you the number of times I’ve run into an old friend on a random street corner… those kismet moments seem to happen a lot in New York, and it’s always surprising and wonderful.”

Plan Your Broadway Night

Whether you’re a lifelong Harry Potter fan or simply looking for a spectacular introduction to Broadway, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child offers a magical night out in NYC. Pair it with Skelley’s insider tips, and you’ve got the perfect recipe for an unforgettable New York experience.

Follow John Skelley on Instagram at @john_skelley for more behind-the-scenes glimpses into life on Broadway.